Search Willoughby Cay Villas
Willoughby Cay Villas for Sale
MOVE-IN READY WITH A NEW 2026 ROOF! Beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 2-bath villa with a 2-car garage, tucked away on a quiet cul-de-sac street in the sought-after gated co...
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- B26082105 MLS
- Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay Bldg.
- 34997 Zip Code
- Willoughby (Aka Willoughby Cay) SubDv.
Very nice Willoughby Cay Villa available for immediate occupancy. Gated community. New metal roof 2024. New refrigerator 2024. Ideal cul-de-sac location with minimal traf...
- 2 Beds
- 2 Baths
- M20056612 MLS
- Willoughby 18 Bldg.
- 34997 Zip Code
- Willoughby 18 SubDv.
Welcome to this beautifully maintained 3 bedroom, 2 bath villa nestled in a quiet gated community. Offering over 1500 ft.² of comfortable living space, this lovely home f...
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- M20056839 MLS
- Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay Bldg.
- 34997 Zip Code
- Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay SubDv.
Nestled at the end of a cul-de-sac, this spacious 2/2/2/ villa with a den is located in the desirable GATED community of Willoughby Cay. The light filled, open floor pla...
- 2 Beds
- 2 Baths
- B26073729 MLS
- Willoughby Cay Bldg.
- 34997 Zip Code
- Willoughby (Aka Willoughby Cay) SubDv.
Willoughby Cay Villas for Sale in Stuart, FL
Willoughby Cay is a small community of about 54 single-story villas on SE Bridgetown Court and SE Tidewater Place, off Willoughby Boulevard in Stuart, Martin County, Florida (ZIP 34997). Built in the early 2000s, the villas look out over a lake, and recent listings describe a gated entry. This page gathers every Willoughby Cay listing in one live feed.
Thinking about buying or selling in Willoughby Cay?
Free, no-obligation home value report and a local answer to any Willoughby Cay question.
Call (772) 359-1926What's My Willoughby Cay Home Worth?Get Pre-QualifiedRE/MAX serving Willoughby Cay and Stuart
Willoughby Cay at a Glance
| Location | SE Bridgetown Ct and SE Tidewater Pl, off Willoughby Blvd, Stuart, Martin County, FL 34997 |
|---|---|
| Home types | Single-story villas, about 1,550 sq ft on the Capri model |
| Built | Early 2000s |
| Size | About 54 homes |
| Gate | Gated entry per recent listings |
| 55+ | No |
| Water | Lake views; no boat access |
| HOA | About $330 a month per recent listings, subject to change |
| MLS names | Willoughby Cay, Willoughby 18 Willoughby Cay |
Willoughby Cay in the MLS
Listing agents enter the community as "Willoughby Cay" and sometimes by its plat name, "Willoughby 18." It is a separate community from Courtyards at Willoughby and Willoughby Crescent, which are condominiums nearby. The search on this page pulls only Willoughby Cay listings.
Life at Willoughby Cay
Willoughby Cay is a quiet pocket of single-story villas around a lake, close to Willoughby Golf Club, Kanner Highway shopping and the Willoughby Boulevard corridor. There is no clubhouse; many villas have their own pools.
What the HOA Covers
Per recent listings, the HOA covers landscaping, the gated entry, basic cable, exterior painting and alarm monitoring. Fees and inclusions change, so confirm them with the association before you buy.
What to Check Before You Buy in Willoughby Cay
| HOA and documents | Ask for the HOA budget, rules and any planned assessments, and what the HOA maintains on the building versus the owner. |
|---|---|
| Roof and insurance | Ask about roof age, wind mitigation and insurance cost on the specific villa. |
| Rentals and pets | Confirm the current lease and pet rules with the HOA before you buy. |
If you are financing, call before you write an offer. We are a RE/MAX agent and a licensed loan officer, so we can run the numbers on a specific Willoughby Cay home with you.
Nearby Stuart Communities
Willoughby Cay FAQs
Where is Willoughby Cay?
On SE Bridgetown Court and SE Tidewater Place, off Willoughby Boulevard in Stuart, Martin County, FL 34997.
What kind of homes are in Willoughby Cay?
About 54 single-story villas built in the early 2000s, many with lake views.
Is Willoughby Cay gated?
Recent listings describe a gated entry, and the HOA fee lists the gate as included.
Is Willoughby Cay part of Willoughby Golf Club?
No. It is a separate HOA near the club. Club membership is not included.
What does the Willoughby Cay HOA cover?
Per recent listings, landscaping, the gated entry, basic cable, exterior painting and alarm monitoring. Confirm current fees.
How much do Willoughby Cay villas cost?
Prices move with the market, so the live listings on this page are the best guide, and the sold section below shows recent closed sales. For comparables on a specific home, call (772) 359-1926.
Ready to see Willoughby Cay villas?
Free, no-obligation home value report and a local answer to any Willoughby Cay question.
Call (772) 359-1926What's My Willoughby Cay Home Worth?Get Pre-QualifiedRE/MAX serving Willoughby Cay and Stuart
Recently Sold in Willoughby Cay
Closed sales in Willoughby Cay, updated from the MLS. Want to know what your home would sell for today? Call (772) 359-1926.
Address Search
Interactive Map Search
:format(webp):quality(80)/u.realgeeks.media/stlucieflrealestate/interactive-map-search.png)