By Al Cucuk, RE/MAX broker associate · Sales update live
What are Willoughby Cay homes selling for? The live market snapshot below shows the median sold price, days on market and sold-to-list percentage for every Willoughby Cay sale in the last 12 months. Figures come straight from the MLS through our IDX feed, which updates every 3 minutes. Willoughby Cay is a community in Stuart (34997), and every recent sale is listed on this page with a street-by-street count.
Market snapshot Sales by street What's my home worth? Selling with us Where is Willoughby Cay FAQ Sold homes
Free, no-obligation home value report based on the actual Willoughby Cay sales on this page.
Call (772) 359-1926 What's My Willoughby Cay Home Worth? Buying Your Next Home? Get Pre-Qualified
RE/MAX serving Willoughby Cay and Stuart
Homes sold on each Willoughby Cay street in the last 12 months, most sales first. The counts update automatically from our IDX feed.
No recent sale on your street? Call (772) 359-1926 or contact us, and we will pull the closest comparable sales for your exact home and model.
Two Willoughby Cay homes on the same street can sell for very different prices. These are the things buyers and appraisers compare first:
| Model and size | Square footage, bedrooms and garage size set the starting point. |
|---|---|
| Lot and view | Water, preserve and golf views usually sell for more than interior lots. |
| Pool | A private pool widens the buyer pool in Stuart. |
| Roof and windows | Roof age and impact windows or shutters drive buyers' insurance quotes, so they show up in offers. |
| Updates | Kitchen, baths, flooring and A/C age are the biggest condition items. |
| Presentation | Clean, well-photographed, fairly priced homes sell faster and closer to asking. |
For a free comparison against the Willoughby Cay sales on your street, call (772) 359-1926 or request your Willoughby Cay home value. You can also see the full Willoughby Cay market report with list price, sold price and days on market for every sale.
| Location | Stuart, FL 34997 |
|---|---|
| HOA | Call (772) 359-1926 for the current amount (subject to change) |
Having the HOA documents and your roof, A/C and insurance details ready before you list helps buyers write a clean offer. Shopping instead? See all Willoughby Cay homes for sale.
Willoughby Cay is in Stuart (34997).
| Destination | Distance | Typical drive |
|---|---|---|
| Downtown Stuart and the Riverwalk | About 4.5 miles | 11 to 15 minutes |
| Cleveland Clinic Martin Health hospital | About 5 miles | 12 to 17 minutes |
| Treasure Coast Square | About 8 miles | 20 to 28 minutes |
| Downtown Jensen Beach | About 10 miles | 21 to 29 minutes |
| Stuart Beach Closest beach, on Hutchinson Island | About 8.5 miles | 18 to 26 minutes |
| Palm Beach International Airport (PBI) Most major airlines | About 37 miles | 41 to 53 minutes |
Distances and drive times are approximate. Open Willoughby Cay in Google Maps
It depends on your model, size, view, pool, roof age and updates. The market snapshot on this page shows the current Willoughby Cay median sold price. A free comparison against the sales on your street gives you a number for your exact home. Call (772) 359-1926.
The Willoughby Cay market report lists every sale in the last 12 months with its sold price and sold date.
The market snapshot shows the median days on market for Willoughby Cay over the last 12 months. Well-priced, updated homes usually sell faster than that.
The sold-to-list percentage in the market snapshot shows how close Willoughby Cay homes have sold to their final asking price over the last 12 months.
The Sales by Street list on this page counts every Willoughby Cay sale in the last 12 months by street. The list updates automatically, most sales first.
See the live listings on the Willoughby Cay homes for sale page.
The monthly fee depends on the home and is subject to change, so call (772) 359-1926 for the current amount on a specific home.
Often, yes, depending on your finances. As a RE/MAX agent, we can review your options before you list. Call (772) 359-1926.
Willoughby Cay is in the 34997 zip code in Stuart, Florida.
The closest beach is Stuart Beach, about 8.5 miles or 18 to 26 minutes away.
Free, no-obligation home value report based on the Willoughby Cay sales below.
Call (772) 359-1926 What's My Willoughby Cay Home Worth? Get Pre-Qualified
RE/MAX serving Willoughby Cay and Stuart
Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. MLS/IDX data and HOA details are subject to change. Questions or updates? Contact us or call (772) 359-1926. Al Cucuk, RE/MAX broker associate.
2/2/2 PLUS DEN OR FAMILY ROOM, WATERFRONT POOL HOME WITH NEW ROOF (2025) AND IMPACT GLASS THROUGHOUT! Nestled within the highly desirable Willoughby Cay community, this ...
Discover this impeccably remodeled 2-bedroom, 2-bath villa with a spacious den, perfectly positioned in the heart of town with tranquil lakefront views and a new 2024 sta...
Welcome to 4662 SE Bridgetown Court, a beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath villa nestled within the gated community of Willoughby Cay. From the moment you arrive, th...
| Stuart | Jensen Beach |
| Palm City | Hutchinson Island |
| Port St. Lucie | Hobe Sound |
| Willoughby Cay For Sale | Willoughby Cay Recently Sold |
| Willoughby Cay Market Report |
| Circle Bay Yacht Club | Windjammer |
| Montego Cove | Hidden Harbour Estates |
| Conquistador | Pierpoint Yacht Club |
| Twin Lakes South | Cedar Pointe |
| Waterfront Homes | Waterfront Condos |
| Gated Communities | 55+ Communities |
| Condos | Townhomes |
| Pool Homes | Luxury Homes |
| Luxury Condos | Duplexes & Multifamily |
| Banyan House | Conquistador |
| Pierpoint Yacht Club | St. Lucie Estates |
| Port Sewall | Fisherman's Village |
| Shurwood Gardens | Cedar Pointe |
| Sewall's Point |
| Circle Bay Yacht Club | Windjammer |
| Poppleton Creek | Tierra Verde |
| Towne Park North |
| North River Shores | The Estuary |
| Sunset Cove | Terrace Gardens |
| Mariner Cay | Hidden Harbour Estates |
| Montego Cove | Rocky Point |
| Dixie Park | Coral Gardens |
| 34994 Homes | 34996 Homes |
| 34997 Homes | Condos Under $200K |
| Homes & Condos Under $300K | Homes Under $400K |
| Homes $500K-$750K | All Stuart Homes |